August 19, 2026
Committee Members
- Douglas N. Harris (Committee Chair), Professor and Chair of Economics, Schlieder Foundation Chair in Public Education, School of Liberal Arts
- Michael Cunningham (Committee Vice-Chair), Co-Chair, President’s Commission on Tulane Values, Professor, School of Science and Engineering, Associate Provost for Graduate Studies and Research
- Mollye Demosthenidy (Committee Vice-Chair), Co-Chair, President’s Commission on Tulane Values, Dean, Newcomb-Tulane College
- Rosalind Butler, Chair, Staff Advisory Council; Director of Workplace Excellence and Community Relations, Freeman School of Business
- Will Ferbos, Administrative Liaison to the Commission on Tulane Values; Vice President for University Relations and Deputy Chief of Staff to the President
- Shriya Dev, GAPSA President, Master of Public Health Student, Celia Scott Weatherhead School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine
- Donald Gaver, Vice-Chair of Tulane University Senate, Alden J. “Doc” Laborde Professor, School of Science and Engineering
- Paulo Goes, Dean, Freeman School of Business
- Victor Holtcamp, Associate Professor and Department Chair, School of Liberal Arts
- Amelia Manning, Dean, School of Professional Advancement
- Heather Marinaro, Vice-Chair, Staff Advisory Council; Senior Financial Service Manager, Institutional Planning and Budget
- William A. Marko, Member, Board of Tulane
- Ambika Prasad, Professor of Practice, School of Professional Advancement
- Michael Rubenstein, B’90, L’93, Past-President of the Tulane Alumni Association
- Stacy Seicshnaydre, Professor and Vice Dean, School of Law
Charge of the Committee
As stated on the university website (January 23, 2026):
“Institutional neutrality is critical to fostering a campus environment in which academic freedom and academic excellence can thrive. By design, universities are comprised of members from the widest possible array of backgrounds and viewpoints, to a greater degree than perhaps any other institution. When we ensure that all members' views are protected and encouraged, we open new pathways for discovery, innovation, and creativity.
With this in mind, Tulane University senior leadership has adopted the principle of institutional neutrality, as noted in messages to the university community in Fall 2024 and Fall 2025. This means that the university will refrain from taking an official public position on most issues, ensuring that individual members of our community are free to express their own opinions as citizens and scholars. However, institutional neutrality does not restrict leadership from publicly engaging in matters that directly impact our core academic functions.
A number of questions have arisen across the university regarding the practical application of institutional neutrality in different contexts. The charge of this ad-hoc committee of the President’s Commission on Tulane Values will be to identify the questions that need to be answered regarding how neutrality applies to all members of the Tulane community. Additionally, the ad-hoc committee will consult with university leadership as principled neutrality extends throughout the university.”
Background
The Kalven Report is easily the most widely cited document on institutional neutrality (henceforth “I.N.”). That report is also mentioned in the committee charge. Therefore, we begin by summarizing its key points.
I.N. is defined by how university actions relate to the university’s mission and core functions. On the first point, the Kalven Report notes: “The mission of the university is the discovery, improvement, and dissemination of knowledge.” The Kalven Report goes on to describe the intended outcomes of this mission:
“[The university’s] domain of inquiry and scrutiny includes all aspects and all values of society. A university faithful to its mission will provide enduring challenges to social values, policies, practices, and institutions. By design and by effect, it is the institution which creates discontent with the existing social arrangements and proposes new ones. In brief, a good university, like Socrates, will be upsetting.”
This statement is important because it helps define what I.N. is not. It is not an attempt to preclude controversy or even to keep the university away from contentious social and political issues. Rather, the intention is to leave those controversies to individuals and small groups of faculty members and students:
“The instrument of dissent and criticism is the individual faculty member or the individual student. The university is the home and sponsor of critics; it is not itself the critic.”
The Kalven Report then goes on to explain how the authors believe the university, as an institution, should act to fulfill the above mission:
“To perform its mission in the society, a university must sustain an extraordinary environment of freedom of inquiry and maintain an independence from political fashions, passions, and pressures. A university, if it is to be true to its faith in intellectual inquiry, must embrace, be hospitable to, and encourage the widest diversity of views within its own community.”
What must the university, as a whole, do to remain “hospitable to, and encourage the widest diversity of views”?
“There is no mechanism by which it [the university] can reach a collective position [about a social or political issue] without inhibiting that full freedom of dissent on which it thrives. It cannot insist that all of its members [i.e., faculty and students] favor a given view of social policy; if it takes collective action, therefore, it does so at the price of censuring any minority who do not agree with the view adopted. In brief, it is a community which cannot resort to majority vote to reach positions on public issues.”
While the report does not make it explicit, a key factor underlying this logic is that the university, as an institution, holds power over the faculty and students. It employs and compensates faculty and issues academic degrees and grades to students. Thus, when the university, as an institution, speaks about anything, it could potentially impose coercive power over students and faculty, limiting free inquiry.
As the Report notes, I.N. does not mean that the university can never speak publicly about anything:
“instances will arise in which the society, or segments of it, threaten the very mission of the university and its values of free inquiry. In such a crisis, it becomes the obligation of the university as an institution to oppose such measures and actively to defend its interests and its values.”
Note here the continued centering of the “very mission of the university,” especially facilitating “free inquiry.”
The Kalven Report also discusses university activities that might be perceived as institutional position-taking that violate I.N. The report mentions that universities sometimes must involve the entire university in:
“situations involving university ownership of property, its receipt of funds, its awarding of honors, its membership in other organizations.”
Speaking up is sometimes necessary to protect free inquiry when outside forces may undermine the ability of the university to carry out its mission. The Report clearly views these instances of institutional position-taking as unusual exceptions:
“These extraordinary instances apart, there emerges, as we see it, a heavy presumption against the university taking collective action or expressing opinions on the political and social issues of the day, or modifying its corporate activities to foster social or political values, however compelling and appealing they may be.”
In other words, the burden of proof is on the side of showing that the university should speak out. The default position, under I.N., is that the university should not.
I.N. has been criticized by those arguing, for example, that there is no such thing as complete neutrality, that I.N. shows a lack of courage, and that it may send the unintended message to students that they should follow the university in not speaking out. But a key point of I.N. is that when universities speak out as institutions, they can discourage free inquiry among faculty and students, inquiry that I.N. critics and supporters alike value highly.
Institutional neutrality is not an end in itself, nor is it a posture of disengagement. Rather, it is a means of protecting and encouraging open discourse within the university. By refraining from taking institutional positions on issues outside its core mission, the university reduces the risk that its considerable authority will inhibit dissent or narrow the range of acceptable viewpoints. In this way, neutrality helps create the conditions under which faculty and students can question prevailing assumptions, advance competing ideas, and engage in rigorous intellectual exchange. Properly understood, institutional neutrality is therefore an active commitment to fostering a pluralistic academic environment, not a withdrawal from difficult or controversial questions.
Questions and Issues Identified by the Committee Regarding Institutional Neutrality
The core functions of Tulane are teaching, research, and service beyond the university; and the committee charge states that “Institutional neutrality does not restrict leadership from publicly engaging in matters that directly impact our core academic functions.” Both statements are aligned with the Kalven Report, which states, “The mission of the university is the discovery, improvement, and dissemination of knowledge.” Accordingly, the university can publicly express opinions on social and political forces that bear on its ability to carry out those functions without violating I.N.
Examples of issues that are related to our core academic functions include, but are not limited to, governmental funding for universities (student financial aid, research funding); other factors that affect the financial position of the university (e.g., taxation of its revenue and assets); governmental or other efforts to collect data that are used in research; governmental or other restrictions and attacks on science and research; governmental or other restrictions and attacks on the content or manner of teaching; governmental or other restrictions and attacks on free speech in private settings; immigration policies that affect the ability of international students and faculty to come to Tulane; matters directly affecting the physical safety of students, staff, and faculty; and the physical environment around the university.
What are forms of speech, and other relevant activities, that could violate I.N.?
Obvious examples of speech include written statements, speeches, comments to reporters, and social media posts. Only speech intended to be public, or reasonably expected to become public, is a potential violation of I.N.
We note the emphasis on “speech” so far. The university also engages in actions that are not explicitly speech and do not clearly convey positions that might impinge, or at least appear to impinge, on academic freedom. Two of the most important examples are the selection of speakers for commencements and other university-wide events, and the conferring of honorary degrees.1 It would be unreasonable to attribute all the views of these invited speakers and honorees to the university itself, especially since part of the university’s job is to facilitate inquiry and encourage expression of, and inquiry into, the “widest diversity of views.” As such, the university may invite a speaker with whom it disagrees, but whose voice is nonetheless an important part of the public debate. The university is free to invite or honor whomever it wishes in these roles without threatening free inquiry or I.N.
The reverse case is also relevant: whether and when the university might block a speaker invited by a unit within the university (e.g., a student group, department, or program). Given the aim of supporting free inquiry and “the widest diversity of views,” there is a strong presumption against blocking speakers. To be considered neutral, such blocks would have to clearly and strongly relate to some other fundamental element of the university’s mission, such as student/employee safety or a severe threat to carrying out other elements of the university’s core mission.
The same general analysis applies to external donations to the university. Again, in general, acceptance of donations does not constitute adherence to the beliefs of the donor, even when the donor’s beliefs may be controversial. There may be exceptions where a donation, perhaps because of its size, may make faculty and students feel pressured to adopt the positions of donors. This would be a violation of free expression, and even if not a violation of I.N. per se, it would be incumbent on the university to take affirmative steps to counteract such perceptions and pressures.
In addition to the above examples and those in the Kalven Report, actions that may be perceived as position-taking include decisions about hiring faculty with particular specialties, hiring leaders who have expressed social-political views in the past, and investing university funds. Based on our reading of the Kalven Report, these actions cannot violate I.N. because, while they involve value judgments and priorities, they do not involve taking clear positions that could be reasonably judged as coercive by students or faculty members.
Generally, no. The core issue with I.N., as we and the Kalven Report have emphasized, is whether the issue directly relates to the university’s mission and core functions. This means that the university may speak out on issues regardless of any perceived controversy or political alignment.
We consider two types of examples. The first involves actions related to the democratic process (e.g., a campus voter registration drive). While this gets the university “involved in politics,” it does so in a way that does not involve taking a political position on specific issues. Moreover, a key element of the university's mission is to prepare students for informed citizenship and constructive participation in a democratic society. So, actions encouraging democratic participation are generally not violations of institutional neutrality.
The second example pertains to actions of the university that, while potentially controversial, are part of the ordinary course of doing business. In most of these cases (e.g., decisions about required vaccines), the university cannot avoid making a decision and therefore cannot, logically speaking, remain neutral.
The level of controversy of any given topic is largely irrelevant to I.N. determinations. The key criterion is how closely the proposed institutional statement is aligned with the core functions of the university.
In I.N., whose actions are generally interpreted as representing the “institution”?
It seems clear that when the president, provost, and chair of the board of trustees speak, they are doing so on behalf of the institution, regardless of the form or context of the speech (more on form and context later). This means that they cannot make public statements that do not pertain to the university’s core mission without the university community viewing them as the position of the university. Conversely, faculty, staff, students, and student groups never speak for the institution.2
Below, we discuss several more ambiguous cases:
- The University Senate. The University Senate occupies a distinctive position in the institutional neutrality framework.3 Because its jurisdiction explicitly encompasses all matters of general university concern, and because it is chaired ex officio by the president of the university, formal Senate actions such as adopted resolutions or official positions should be understood as representing the institution, not merely the aggregate views of its individual members. Practically speaking, the Senate chair (the president) bears responsibility for ensuring that proposed motions and resolutions remain within the scope of the university’s core mission before they are brought to a vote.
This does not constrain individual senators, who retain full academic freedom and the right to speak in their personal capacities as faculty members, staff, or students. The constraint applies only to formal, adopted actions of the Senate as a body. - Deans. Deans present an ambiguous case because they are both faculty members, with their own expertise and academic freedom, and administrators who have power over faculty and students. Deans, however, are primarily administrators because their position descriptions rarely include significant expectations of scholarly activities.
- Center, institute, and program directors who are staff/administrators, NOT faculty members. Relative to deans, these directors have less power, especially over faculty (all tenure-line faculty have tenure homes in schools or departments), as well as students (unless they offer courses or majors/minors that involve graduation requirements). What academic freedom these staff/administrators might have is to be determined separately by the university, may vary from person to person, and is beyond the scope of this document. If these non-faculty directors are judged to have academic freedom, then this must be weighed against the fact that they also have less power over faculty and students.
- Department chairs and center, institute, and program directors who are also faculty members. In these cases, and unless otherwise stated in position descriptions, these individuals are primarily acting as faculty members and their speech is covered under academic freedom. Their speech is outside the scope of I.N.
- Members of the board of trustees other than the board chair. The board of trustees has power over faculty promotions; therefore, the views of the board could be reasonably seen as coercive. On the other hand, board members have other responsibilities outside the university. As in all the ambiguous cases above, the manner and context of the speech may be important (more on this below). The board of trustees itself might choose to impose its own code of conduct that further limits this form of speech because of I.N. or for other reasons.
In these ambiguous cases, there are situations where the above groups may speak out on topics that go beyond the university or unit missions, but their latitude is more limited than that of faculty members and students. The next question further elaborates on these ambiguous cases.
In the ambiguous cases, how does the manner of speech affect I.N.?
In the clear-cut cases (president, provost, and board chair on the one hand, and department chairs and faculty center/institute/program directors on the other), the manner of speech is largely irrelevant. However, in the ambiguous cases (deans, non-faculty center/institute/program directors, and non-chair board members), the manner of speech may tip the balance. Whether an action is a violation of I.N. in these cases may depend on whether those speaking or acting focus on the Tulane credentials that most clearly convey their expertise and downplay their unit leadership roles. For example, deans could avoid violating I.N. by focusing on their academic degrees and faculty positions, not their administrative role, and by emphasizing that they are not speaking for the school (unless the speech pertains to their school’s mission and functions in the way described above and elsewhere in this document).
In general, yes. I.N. implies a strong presumption against any unit making pronouncements as a unit (e.g., “the Department/Center/Institute/Program of X is against position Y”). Moreover, in the same way the university president and provost are limited to statements about the university’s core mission and academic functions, so, too, are leaders of these smaller units limited for purposes of I.N. This is true for the same reasons as for the university. The leaders of these units have some power over faculty and students connected to the units.
We also note that smaller units may have missions distinct from those of the university, which may affect the core academic functions on which they might take institutional positions. So long as these additional functions have been regularly and publicly stated (e.g., on the unit’s website), they are relevant to determinations of I.N.
As noted earlier, the way this plays out for individual leaders of the above units depends on the type of unit and the faculty status of its leaders. Again, department chairs and most directors function primarily as faculty members, so nothing they say as individuals is a violation of I.N.
In general, no. The Kalven Report does mention that the university should be able to “defend its interests and its values” (emphasis added). Moreover, as with most other universities, Tulane has stated values (e.g., “leading for a better tomorrow”), which, by definition, are not neutral.
At first, this point appears to pose some difficulty in operationalizing I.N. because the university’s values can apply beyond its mission. However, the Kalven Report is clear that the focus should remain on the core mission and functions. To reconcile these points, we note that Tulane’s values are mainly guides for how the university carries out the core academic activities that are at the heart of I.N. Returning to the “leading for a better tomorrow” example, this value does not mean that the university can comment on anything in the world having to do with “leadership” or “a better tomorrow” and still be consistent with I.N.
To the extent that the university relies on its values as a basis for public comment, this still must be done, for I.N. purposes, in a way that is connected to the university’s mission and core functions. To avoid an overly broad interpretation, the university, in these cases, should rely on values that have been previously and explicitly stated (e.g., on a website or annual report) to determine whether position-taking violates I.N. In this sense, these additional values clarify what might be relevant to the core university mission and functions but without significantly broadening what the university may speak about.
Nothing here should be construed to inhibit the university from stating and reaffirming its values, speaking openly about them, or discussing their implications for how the university carries out its mission. While the university, under I.N., is limited to speaking on matters directly related to its core mission and functions, it again gives faculty and students the opportunity to apply those values more broadly. We emphasize again that academic freedom and freedom of expression are the core university values that I.N. is intended to protect.
Is fulfilling I.N. sufficient to ensure academic freedom and free inquiry?
No. The larger aim of the university is for faculty and students to believe that they can and should think, speak, and investigate freely without fear of repercussion from the university, especially in high-stakes decisions such as employment, promotion, and compensation (for faculty), and grading and degree conferral (for students).4 I.N. is only one step toward that end. Especially as others might follow the university’s lead and avoid position-taking or protest, the university also needs to explicitly reiterate the goals of I.N., explicitly encourage position-taking by students and faculty, and perhaps, in some cases, make public comments that defend the rights of students and faculty to speak where that right is publicly attacked.
In what ways does I.N. pertain to students?
As noted in the Kalven Report, a key purpose of I.N. is to facilitate free inquiry among students (and faculty). As such, students cannot be punished for their political and social views. Similar to academic freedom for faculty, I.N. is intended to ensure that students are free to express their views without repercussions from the university.
Also, similar to university faculty, students and student groups never speak for the university as a whole. (That is, student and faculty groups should not be considered “units” in ways that departments and programs are above.) Therefore, statements by students, student groups, and student government cannot be violations of I.N.
None of this means that students and student groups have no boundaries regarding speech and behavior. These boundaries are established by the Student Code of Conduct and other university policies.
Does I.N. ever compel the university leadership to speak out?
No, the fact that the university may speak on these matters without violating I.N. does not mean it must do so in all cases. Deciding whether to speak is a matter of university strategy. In other words, I.N. is more proscriptive than prescriptive.
In addition to the steps described above, it is important that everyone in the university avoid giving the impression that they speak for the university, as an institution, and take care to accurately portray any positions the university has or has not taken. As with other key principles, such as academic freedom, our success with institutional neutrality depends on the entire university community.
Are there any exceptions to the above?
As with any set of principles, there may be times when one principle needs to be violated in order to meet other principles. I.N. is meant as a guide. For it to be useful as a principle, however, we should expect that exceptions will be rare. Otherwise, the principle begins to lose its meaning.
1 These two examples differ in one important respect. When people are invited to speak at a university, this is generally accompanied by some type of public discussion and debate. But when people are invited to be commencement speakers, the communication goes in one direction. In this respect, it is more reasonable to view the commencement speaker as making a statement on behalf of the university, but there is still enough detachment that neither example constitutes position-taking.
2 While student groups cannot speak for the university, the committee expressed interest in having greater clarity from the administration in what student groups are allowed, and not allowed, to do. As we note later, this is partially addressed in the Student Code of Conduct.
3 The Senate’s “purview consists of all matters of general University concern, especially those which affect at least two academic divisions.” This means that all aspects of the Senate’s work fall within the scope of the university’s core mission and functions.
4 It may be especially important for the administration to communicate to faculty that they should not hold students’ beliefs against them in grading and assessment.